HPBA’s Oral Arguments in U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit

9/11/12: Jack Goldman, President & CEO of the Hearth Patio & Barbecue Association, reported on HPBA’s day in court:

“Today, HPBA presented its oral arguments to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit on the Department of Energy’s (DOE) regulation of decorative vented gas fireplaces. HPBA was well represented by Barton Day, of the law firm Polsinelli & Shughart, who has worked tirelessly since 2010 on the issue. Barton eloquently laid out why decorative gas hearth products are unlawfully classified as a covered product in DOE’s Final Rule in April 2010, and illegally regulated in that rule and the subsequent rule, issued in November 2011.

The argument – scheduled for approximately 30 minutes – lasted approximately one hour and 20 minutes due to extensive questioning from the panel of three judges. The three judges listened and questioned Barton on how decorative hearth products are different from heater-rated products, how DOE circumvented the statutory process and how DOE has no authority to impose design requirements, such as a ban on standing pilot lights. The judges also questioned the Department of Justice lawyer representing DOE extensively, and appeared skeptical of DOE’s claim that it is not regulating decorative fireplaces but only “distinguishing” them from heater-rated fireplaces. DOE’s lawyer was also questioned on whether the department had the authority to regulate these products under the Energy Policy and Conservation Act. Although it is impossible to predict how a court will rule based on questioning during oral argument, the proceeding appeared to go well for HPBA.

The judges’ decision will most likely be handed down at the end of this year or in early 2013.”

Think good thoughts! Let’s hope that reasonable heads prevail.


hudson beauduy 13-09-2012, 16:20

this argument about standing pilot dont make no sence .it is safe and reliable and cost of this it is so low , and it is 5 time more greeen than your cooking stove GAS logs OR vent free GAS logs or safe and effficient and you can controll tha BTU.


Leave a Reply

Sign the Petition


How did we get here? What is the basis for the US Department of Energy's assault on gas logs? Here is the background information ...


The Threat

The US Department of Energy Proposed Rule would harm the market for gas logs, and severely limit consumer choice ...



We're fighting for the survival of vented gas logs against the US Government, and we need all the help we can get. Here is what you can do to help save gas logs ...


Fallacy of ‘”Decorative” 9000 BTU

900 btu

With the stroke of a pen, the US Department of Energy declared that (as of July 1, 2011), a gas log set must not consume more that 9000 BTU/hour to be termed "decorative". If it consumes more gas than that, it must meet efficiency ratings for which no testing methodogy exists. Watch this video where Rett Rasmussen illustrates the fallacy of 9000 BTU/Hour being "decorative."

Watch Video